Dear reader,
My name is Joha-Maine Andrianatos, Certified Fraud Examiner (CFE), Chartered Business Accountant in Practice (CIBA), and General Tax Practitioner (SAIT). I have spent close to two decades pulling apart payroll fraud, fake invoices, shell company schemes, procurement kickbacks, and financial statement manipulation across South African businesses.
Earlier this week, on 20 October 2026, I attended Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr’s Annual Company Law Developments Conference. One of the sessions was on majority rule and the protections the law gives to the minority. Most of the room was thinking about boardroom fights. I kept writing one question in the margin of my notes: what happens to my evidence if the mandate that sent me in was an ambush?
Every forensic examiner knows the phone call. “The board has resolved to appoint you. Start Monday. Image the laptops.” We ask about scope, fees and timelines. Far fewer of us ask how that resolution was passed, who was told about it, and who was deliberately left out.
The law
The Companies Act 71 of 2008 lets the majority run the company, but it also builds in brakes. Section 74 allows directors to decide by round robin, without a meeting, but only if each director has received notice of the matter to be decided. Section 76(3) requires directors to act in good faith, for a proper purpose and in the best interests of the company. Sections 71(3) and 71(5) require notice, reasons and a fair chance to respond before a director is removed, and let the removed director ask a court to review the decision. Section 163 gives a shareholder or director relief from conduct that is oppressive or unfairly prejudicial. Section 2(2)(d) widens “control” so that informal influence also counts. On top of that, the MOI or shareholders agreement often gives the minority veto rights over reserved matters.
The cases
In Swanvest 328 v Ensemble Hotel Holdings [2026] ZASCA 101, the Supreme Court of Appeal found oppression where the majority kept denying a minority-nominated director the information he needed to do his job. In Msibithi Investments v African Legend Investment [2025] ZASCA 61, a round-robin share issue passed two days before a meeting called to replace those very directors survived. Notice had been given, and the court found the dominant purpose was a proper one. In Behnst Family Trust v Gattis Ice Cream (WCHC, October 2026), the court set aside resolutions that suspended disciplinary steps against a director’s son. They had been tabled as a foregone conclusion, and the conflicted father never recused himself. The court’s answer was to order an independent investigation.
Why this matters to fraud examiners
- Your authority is only as good as the resolution. If the resolution is set aside, your access to records, systems and devices can be attacked, and the evidence you gathered can be attacked with it.
- Check the paper trail before you image a single drive. Get the resolution, the MOI, the shareholders agreement and proof that every director was given notice.
- Purpose is everything. Record the legitimate business reason for the investigation on day one. An investigation whose real purpose is to shield someone or push a director out is exposed.
- Don’t become the weapon. Under Swanvest, helping to freeze a minority director out of information can itself feed an oppression claim.
- Protect the chain of custody and the instruction trail. Keep a record of who instructed you, when, and on what authority. Where you can, work through attorneys to protect privilege.
- When your mandate is disputed, pause the intrusive steps. Ask for ratification at a properly convened meeting, or a court order.
Good evidence can’t fix a bad mandate.
Sources: Swanvest 328 v Ensemble Hotel Holdings, SCA, 21 July 2026; Msibithi Investments v African Legend Investment, SCA, 14 May 2025; Court intervenes in family business dispute, South African Lawyer, October 2026.
Originally published in my Fraud Talk newsletter on LinkedIn.
Suspect fraud in your business? Book a confidential consultation.
