By Joha-Maine Andrianatos, Certified Fraud Examiner (CFE), Chartered Business Accountant in Practice (CIBA), General Tax Practitioner (SAIT)
Dear reader,
Here is the story of Janet, shared with permission and used almost verbatim:
I never thought I would be the type of person to fall for a scam. Like many people, I always believed I would spot the warning signs immediately. But scams are becoming increasingly sophisticated, personal, and convincing — and I recently learned that the hard way.
I am sharing my experience in the hope that it prevents someone else from going through the same thing.
It started with a WhatsApp message from what appeared to be my boss. The profile picture was his face, his name appeared exactly as I knew it, and the conversation felt legitimate. The only unusual detail was that the message came from a different phone number. I thought it was strange, but not strange enough to question. After all, people sometimes use different numbers for work or personal reasons.
The message said he was in a meeting and urgently needed my assistance with a task. Naturally, I agreed to help.
He asked where my nearest supermarket was. Since he roughly knows the area where I live, this did not seem suspicious. I told him my nearest Pick n Pay. He then explained that he urgently needed a card for a client presentation and would guide me through what he needed. I thought a thank-you card or something and agreed.
I was instructed to go to the store immediately and was asked how long it would take so he could look at his phone. I told him I left quickly. After arriving, I sent photos of the card stand and asked what type of card he needed, expecting him to choose an ordinary greeting card or something related to a client gift. Instead, he sent a picture of an Apple Store card and instructed me to purchase two cards, each loaded with R1,000.
I confirmed the amount before paying, believing I was simply helping with an urgent work matter.
After payment, I sent proof of purchase. I was then told to scratch the backs of the cards and send photographs of the codes so that they could be “confirmed” before I left the shop.
Again, because I believed I was dealing with my employer, I complied.
The scam only began to reveal itself when I was asked to buy an additional R3,000 in gift cards. Right then and there, I knew my boss would never expect this and knew it was a scam.
I tried calling him directly, but the messages continued: “I’m in a meeting. I’ll call you in 30 min.” When I insisted that he excuse himself from the meeting and call me, the communication stopped.
That was when it was confirmed that I had been scammed.
The most disturbing part is how personal and believable it all was. The scammer used my boss’s profile image and name and clearly knew enough about my working relationship to realise I would likely respond quickly to his request. I would never have done this for a stranger.
This experience taught me an important lesson: Never trust a profile picture, a saved name, or even familiar wording. Verify first, even though it sounds urgent.
If anyone — even someone who appears to be your employer, colleague, friend, or family member — asks you to urgently purchase gift cards, send money, share codes, or make payments, stop and call them directly on a trusted number before taking any action.
Scammers are relying on urgency, trust, and familiarity. Don’t let embarrassment stop you from speaking about it. If sharing my story helps even one person avoid becoming a victim, then at least some good can come from an expensive lesson.”
Key Red Flags in This Scam (and Similar Impersonation Attacks)
This is a classic boss/CEO gift card scam (a Business Email Compromise (BEC) variant using WhatsApp). Here are the critical red flags to watch for:
- Impersonation of authority: The scammer used the boss’s exact name and profile picture. They often scrape LinkedIn, company websites, or breached data for this information.
- Urgency and pressure: Phrases like “I’m in a meeting,” “do this immediately,” “I need it now for a client presentation.” Legitimate bosses rarely create this level of time pressure for gift card purchases.
- Unusual request + escalation: Asking an employee to buy gift cards (especially Apple/iTunes cards, which are hard to trace) and then scratch/send the codes. Requests quickly escalate in value once the victim complies.
- Different contact method: Message from a new or unknown number, even if the name and photo match.
- Avoidance of verification: Excuses like “I’m in a meeting, can’t talk” when the victim tries to call the real boss on a known number.
Scammers thrive on the combination of trust + urgency + familiarity. They know employees want to be helpful and responsive, especially to senior people.
Practical Steps to Protect Yourself and Your Team
- Verify independently — Always call or message the person on a known, saved number. Do not reply via the same channel.
- Never buy gift cards for “work” under pressure — Legitimate company expenses go through proper procurement or reimbursement processes.
- Train your team — Share this story in team meetings. New employees are especially vulnerable.
- Report it — In South Africa, report to your bank, SAPS, and the Cybercrime Unit. Gift cards are difficult to recover once codes are sent.
- Company policies — Establish clear rules: No urgent gift card purchases without written confirmation and verification.
Stay vigilant. Fraudsters are professionals who study human behaviour. The best defence is awareness and a healthy dose of scepticism, even (especially) when the request comes from someone you trust.
If you or someone you know has fallen victim to a similar scam, feel free to reach out — speaking about it reduces the shame and helps others.
Joha-Maine Andrianatos
Certified Fraud Examiner (CFE) | Forensic Accounting | Business Consultant | Tax Advisory
Originally published in my Fraud Talk newsletter on LinkedIn.
Suspect fraud in your business? Book a confidential consultation.
