Dear reader,
My name is Joha-Maine Andrianatos, Certified Fraud Examiner (CFE), Chartered Business Accountant in Practice (CIBA), and General Tax Practitioner (SAIT). I have spent close to two decades pulling apart payroll fraud, fake invoices, shell company schemes, procurement kickbacks, and financial statement manipulation across South African businesses.
This week a KwaZulu-Natal judgment caught my eye, and it isn’t the fraud that makes it remarkable. A Durban man was sentenced to seven years for a R464,983.63 invoice fraud. The High Court has now overturned both his conviction and his sentence. It made no finding on whether he did it. It found that the person defending him wasn’t authorised to stand in that courtroom.
The fraud
The state alleged that Farouk Oosman Alijan, acting with others, got Bid Freight Port Operations in Durban to pay invoices from Feroz Trucking (Pty) Ltd for transport services that were presented as genuine. Anyone who has read my earlier piece, The Invoice You Never Questioned, will recognise the pattern. A document looked right, so it was paid. Mr Alijan pleaded guilty in August 2024 and in November 2024 was sentenced to seven years, two of them suspended.
The twist
At trial he was represented by a candidate legal practitioner. When the Legal Practice Council was asked, it confirmed it had no registered practical vocational training contract for him during the period he appeared in court. The court noted that his principal appeared to have condoned this. In court, he even tried to enter a plea before the charge had been put to the accused, and the magistrate had to correct him.
The High Court found the representation was not merely irregular but prejudicial, and likely made the trial unfair. The matter goes back for a fresh trial before a different presiding officer, if the Director of Public Prosecutions reinstates the charge.
Why this matters to fraud examiners
- Fraud runs on unverified trust. Bid Freight trusted invoices nobody tested. Mr Alijan trusted a “lawyer” whose standing nobody checked. The same weakness appears on both sides of one case.
- Credentials are a control, not a courtesy. Checking the LPC roll, SAICA, SAIPA or CIBA membership, CIPC records or a supplier’s bank details takes minutes. We demand it of suppliers, so we should demand it of professionals.
- One unchecked gap can undo everything. An investigation, a prosecution and a guilty plea were wiped out by a single unverified qualification. For the victim, that means another trial, more cost and a longer wait for recovery.
- Gatekeepers only work if the gate is real. Attorneys, accountants and auditors are relied on because they’re regulated. When someone bypasses that, everyone downstream carries the risk.
Verify the invoice, verify the supplier, and verify the professional. “They told me they were qualified” has never been a control.
Source: IOL, 16 October 2026.
Originally published in my Fraud Talk newsletter on LinkedIn.
Suspect fraud in your business? Book a confidential consultation.
